||
home
|| back
||
Burma-Singapore Axis:
Globalising the Heroin Trade
BY Leslie Kean & Dennis Bernstein
Spring 1998 - Covert Action Quarterly
SINGAPORE'S economic linkage with Burma
is one of the most vital factors for the survival of Burma's military regime,"
says Professor Mya Maung, a Burmese economist based in Boston. This link,
he continues, is also central to "the expansion of the heroin trade." Singapore
has acieved the distinction of being the Burmese junta's number one business
partner - both largest trading partner and largest foreign investor. More
than half these investments, totaling upwards of $1.3 billion, are in partnership
with Burma's infamous heroin kingpin Lo Hsing Han who now controls a substantial
portion of the world's opium trade. The close political, economic and military
relationship between the two countries facilitates the weaving of millions
of narco-dollars into the legitimate world economy Singapore has become
a major player in Asian commerce. According to Steven Green, US Ambassador
to Singapore, free market policies have "allowed this small country to
develop one of the world's most successful trading and investment economies."
Singapore also has a strong role in the
powerful 132-member country World Trade Organization. Indeed, the tiny
China Sea island of three and a half million people is known far and wide
as the blue chip of the region - a financial trading base and a route for
the vast sums of money that flow in and out of Asia.
If the brutal Burmese dictatorship's international
pariah status is of any concern to its more powerful partner, Singapore
shows no sign of it. Following the March 24 visit of Singapore's Prime
Minister Goh Chok Tong to Rangoon, a Singapore spokesperson proclaimed,
"Singapore and Myanmar should continue to explore areas where they can
complement each other." As both countries continue to celebrate their "complementary"
relationship, the international community must take note of the powerful
support this relationship provides both to Burma's illegitimate regime
and to its booming billion dollar drug trade.
Drugs 'R' Us
THE Burmese military dictatorship - known
by the acronym slorc for State Law and Order Restoration Council until
it changed its name to the State Peace and Development Council (spdc) last
November - depends on the resources of Burma's drug barons for its financial
survival. Since it seized power in 1988, opium production has doubled,
equaling all legal exports and making the country the world's biggest heroin
supplier. Burma now supplies the US with 60 percent of its heroin imports
and has recently become a major regional producer of methamphetamines.
With 50 percent of the economy unaccounted for, drug traffickers, businessmen
and government officials are able to integrate spectacular profits throughout
Burma's permanent economy. Both the Burmese generals and drug lords have
been able to take advantage of Singapore's liberal banking laws and money
laundering opportunities. In 1991, for eaxample, the slorc laundered $400
million through a Singapore bank which it used as a down payment for Chinese
arms. Despite the large sum, Burma's foreign exchange reserves registered
no change either before or after the sale. With no laws to prevent money
laundering, Singapore is widely reported to be a financial haven for Burma's
elite, including its two most notorious traffickers, Lo Hsing Han and Khun
Sa (also known by his Chinese name Chang Qifu).
SLORC cut a deal with Khun Sa for his
"surrender" in early 1996, allowing him protection and business opportunities
in exchange for retirement from the drug trade.
Khun Sa now bills himself as "a commercial
real estate agent who also has a foot in the Burmese construction industry."
Already in control of a bus route into the northern poppy growing region
where the military is actively involved in the drug business, he is now
investing $250 million in a new highway between Rangoon and Mandalay, an
spdc cabinet member confirmed. "The Burmese government says one thing but
does another," according to Banphot Piamdi, director of Thailand's Northern
Region's Narcotics Suppression Center. "It claims to have subdued Khun
Sa's group...However the fact is that the group under the supervision of...Khun
Sa's son has received permission from Rangoon to produce narcotics in the
areas along the Thai-Burmese border." Khun Sa's son is not the only trafficker
reaping benefits in the Shan State area which borders Thailand and China
and serves as Burma's primary poppy growing area. Field intelligence and
ethnic militia sources consistently report a pattern of Burmese military
involvement with drug production in these remote areas. Government troops
offer protection to the heroin and amphetamine refineries in the area in
exchange for payoffs and gifts, such as Toyota sedans, pistols and army
uniforms. The only access to the refineries is through permits issued by
Burmese military intelligence - without this, the heavily guarded areas
surrounding the refineries are too dangerous to approach. The military
is also involved in protecting the transport of narcotics throughout the
region, which the authorities have sealed off from the outside world.
"There are persistent and reliable reports
that officials, particularly army personnel posted in outlying areas, are
involved in the drug business," confirms the March 1998 US government narcotics
report. "Army personnel wield considerable political clout locally, and
their involvement in trafficking is a significant problem." Intelligence
sources, working for ethnic leaders combating both the drug trade and the
military dictatorship, report that the pattern of government involvement
extends all the way to the top. The central government in Rangoon demands
funds on a regular basis from regional commanders who, in turn, expect
payoffs from the rank and file. The soldiers get the money any way they
can - through smuggling, gambling or selling jade - with drugs being the
most accessible source of revenue in Shan State. The officers in the field
also "tax" refineries, drug transporters, and opium farmers.
At great risk, the intellignce sources
- who go undercover to infiltrate troops in the field -- collect painstakingly
detailed data including names, dates and places, such as these delivered
in March 1998 from Shan State: "On 10th Jan. 98, spdc army no. 65 stationed
at Mong Ton sent 40 troops to Nam Hkek village, Pon Pa Khem village tract,
collected 0.16 kilo of opium per household or [collected payment of] Baht
600. Then the troops sold the collected opium to the drug business men
at the rate of Baht 6000 for 1.6 kilos "
Another report states: "Troops from spdc
Battalion nos. 277 & 65 stationed at Mong Ton are still protecting
heroin refineries situated at Hkai lon, Pay lon & Ho ya areas, Mong
Ton township. Those who can pay B.200,00 per month are allowed to run the
heroin refineries." And: "On 3rd of Jan. 98, Burma Army no. 99 collected
opium tax in Lashio township. They charged 0.32 kilo per household. They
arrested and beat seriously those who failed to give."
These sources also report that Ko Tat,
Private 90900 from spdc battalion no. 525 stationed in Lin Kay, recently
defected from the Burmese army and said that his company had been giving
protection to the opium fields around Ho Mong. While the lower ranked officers
struggle to meet their quotas in the field, the highest levels of the goverment
in the capital city strike deals with Burma's two top traffickers, one
of whom is the prosperous partner of Singapore.
Lo Hsing Han: At Home in Singapore
With massive financial ties to Singapore,
Lo Hsing Han is now one of Burma's top investors. He, along with Khun Sa,
the former "king of opium," is a major player in the Burmese economy.
In the early 1990s, Lo Hsing Han controlled
the most heavily armed drug-trafficking organization in Southeast Asia.
He was arrested in 1973 and sentenced to death, but was freed under a general
amnesty in 1980. Now, like Khun Sa, he wears the public persona of a successful
businessman in Rangoon - where no one does business without close government
cooperation. Although he still overseas rural drug operations with the
status of a godfather, according to US narcotics officials, the notorious
Lo currently serves as an advisor on ethnic affairs to Lt. Gen. Khin Nyunt,
the military intelligence chief and the junta's powerful "Secretary 1."
Lo Hsing Han is the chair of Burma's biggest
conglomerate, Asia World, founded in 1992. His son, Steven Law, is managing
director and also runs three companies in Singapore which are "overseas
branches" of Asia World. Although Singapore is proud of its mandatory death
penalty for small-time narcotics smugglers and heroin addicts, both father
and son travel freely in and out of the friendly island nation. "The family
money is offshore," said a high level US narcotics official. "The old man
is a convicted drug trafficker, so his kid is handling the financial activities."
In 1996, when Law married his Singaporean
business partner in a lavish, well-publicized Rangoon wedding, guests from
Singapore were flown in on two chartered planes. According to a high-level
US government official familiar with the situation, Law's wife Cecilia
Ng operates an underground banking system, and "is a contact for people
in Burma to get their drug money into Singapore, because she has a connection
to the government." The official said that she spends half her time in
Rangoon, half in Singapore; when in Rangoon, she is headquartered at Asia
Lite, a subsidiary of Asia World. The husband-wife team are also the sole
officers and shareholders of Asia World subsidiary, Kokang Singapore Pte
Ltd. Founded in Singapore in 1993 with $4.6 million, the company "engages
in general trading activities in goods/products of all kinds/descriptions."
Singapore's ventures with Asia World include
both government and private investments. Kuok Singapore Ltd., a partner
with Asia World in many ventures, was Burma's largest single real estate
investor as of late 1996, with over $650 million invested. Other Singaporean
companies are mentioned in Asia World's company reports. Sinmardev, another
major Singaporean project linked to Lo's company, is a $207 million industrial
park and port on the outskirts of Rangoon, which broke ground in 1997.
Singaporean entrepreneur Albert Hong, head of Sinmardev, described the
project as the largest foreign investment in Burma outside the energy field.
The Singaporean consortium leads the joint venture along with the Burmese
junta, Lo's Asia World, and a slew of international shareholders.
Kuok Singapore Ltd., Lo Hsing Han's Asia
World, and the Burmese junta are also partners in the luxury Traders Hotel.
The hotel's November 1996 opening ceremony was attended by the Singapore
ambassador, the president of Kuok Singapore, and briefly by Lo Hsing Han
himself. The presiding Burmese minister publicly thanked Steven Law and
the government of Singapore "without whose support and encouragement there
would be very few Singaporean businessmen in our country."
While government and business connections
in Burma and Singapore have boosted Asia World's prospects, other factors
have contributed to the company's extraordinary growth. In the last six
years, Asia World has expanded from a modest trading company to become
Burma's largest and fastest-growing private sector enterprise with interests
in trading, manufacturing, property, industrial investment, development,
construction, transportation, import and distribution, and infrastructure.
"How is it that a company that has a humble beginning trading beans and
pulses is suddenly involved in $200 million projects?" a US government
official said, requesting anonymity. "Where did all that start-up capital
come from?"
The US government ventured a guess in
1996: it denied Asia World's CEO Steven Law a visa to the US "on suspicion
of drug trafficking." Asia World's operations now include a deepwater port
in Rangoon, the Leo Express bus line into Northern Burma, and a $33 million
toll highway from the heart of Burma's poppy-growing region to the China
border. On December 20, the conglomerate opened a wharf with freight handling,
storage, and a customs yard for ships carrying up to 15,000 tons. "If you're
in the dope business, these are the types of things that you've got to
have to be able to move your product," said a high level US narcotics official.
"They have set up institutions to facilitate the movement of drugs. And
in all probability, they are using laundered drug proceeds, or funds generated
from investments of drug trafficking proceeds, to build this infrastructure,"
he added. The activities of Lo's company Asia World have triggered an international
narcotics investigation lead by Washington. US investigators allege that
Asia World's relationship to Singapore paves the way for the narcotics
trade to be woven into all legitimate investments between the two countries.
"Singapore's investments in Burma are opening doors for the drug traffickers,
giving them access to banks and financial systems," said one government
official familiar with the situation.
One Stop Shopping: Intelligence to Repression
THE Burmese junta's control of its impoverished
population through crude methods such as torture, forced labor, and mass
killings leaves it open to international condemnation. In contrast, Singapore
takes a more sophisticated approach to repression, both at home and abroad.
While the island-nation's citizens have material benefits and the appearance
of rule of law, they live in fear of an Orwellian government that closely
monitors every aspect of their lives. The ruling party often sues those
who dare to oppose it on trumped up defamation charges, forcing many into
bankruptcy or exile.
The FBI is investigating complaints by
US citizens of harassment by Singapore's Internal Security Department (ISD).
One California academic, a widely respected specialist on Southeast Asian
affairs who asked not to be identified, says ISD agents broke into his
home because he was working to bring leading Singaporean opposition figure
Tang Liang Hong to an American university. The operatives tore out his
door handle to get in, then searched his computer and desk.
A week later, an Asian man, waiting in
a tree, photographed and videotaped the academic while he walked in the
park. After temporarily blinding the academic with his bright flash, the
man jumped from the tree and made a getaway in his car. Tang - who is facing
a $4.5 million defamation lawsuit by Singaporean senior ministers - was
not surprised by the burglary. "I've been followed everywhere, whether
I was in Hong Kong, Malaysia, Australia or in London," he said in a phone
interview from Australia.
Singapore has been more than willing to
share its expertise in intelligence with its Burmese counterparts. The
Singapore-Myanmar Ministerial-Level Work Committee was set up in 1993 in
Rangoon to "forge mutual benefits in investment, trade and economic sectors."
The committee includes intelligence chief Lt. Gen. Khin Nyunt, other top
Burmese ministers, and high-level Singaporean officials. At the December
23 meeting, Khin Nyunt urged his ministers to give priority to projects
arranged by the Singaporean Government. "Pilot projects are being implemented
to transfer know how to Myanmar," said Khin Nyunt in his address.
One such project is a state-of-the-art
cyber-war center in Rangoon. Burma's military leaders can now intercept
a range of incoming communications - including telephone calls, faxes,
emails and computer data transmissions - from 20 other countries.
The high-tech cyber-war center was built
by Singapore Technologies, the city-state's largest industrial and technology
conglomerate, comprising more than 100 companies. This government-owned
company also provides on-site training at Burma's Defense Ministry complex,
and reportedly passes on its "sophisticated capability" to hundreds of
Burmese "secret police" at an institution inside Singapore.
Burma has no external enemies, but the
ruling junta goes to extremes to terrorize the population through its elaborate
intelligence network. Intelligence officials have already used their newly-acquired
talents from the cyber-war center to arrest pro-democracy activists, and
it is well known that Burma's feared military intelligence often tortures
its victims during lengthy interrogations.
Singaporean companies have also helped
suppress dissent in Burma by supplying the military with arms to use against
its own people. The first shipment of guns and ammunition was delivered
on October 6, 1988. Throughout the month, hundreds of boxes of mortars,
ammunition, and other supplies marked "Allied Ordnance, Singapore" were
unloaded from vessels in Rangoon. Allied Ordnance is a subsidiary of Chartered
Industries of Singapore, the arms branch of Singapore Technologies - the
same government-owned company which built the cyber-war center. The shipments
also included rockets made by Chartered Industries of Singapore under license
from a Swedish company and sold in violation of an agreement with Sweden
requiring authorization for re-exports.
These shipments from Singapore arrived
only weeks after the 1988 military takeover in Rangoon, in which the new
leaders of the SLORC massacred hundreds of peaceful, pro-democracy demonstrators
in the street. These killings followed another wave of government massacres
earlier that summer, when longtime dictator Ne Win struggled to keep power
in the face of nationwide strikes and demonstrations for democracy. He
eventually stepped down but, operating behind the scenes, installed the
puppet SLORC. As the killings continued, thousands of civilians fled the
country fearing for their lives. When numerous countries responded by suspending
aid and Burma's traditional suppliers cut shipments, the SLORC became desperate.
Singapore was the first country to come to its rescue.
Singapore companies have continued to
supply Burma's military, sometimes acting as middlemen for arms from other
countries. In 1989, Israel and Belgium delivered grenade launchers and
anti-tank guns via Singapore. In 1992, Singapore violated the European
Commission arms embargo on the Burmese regime by acting as a broker and
arranging for a $1.5 million shipment of mortars from Portugal.
"It is highly unlikely that any of these
shipments to Burma could have been made without the knowledge and support
of the Singapore Government," wrote William Ashton in Jane's Intelligence
Review. "By assisting with weapons sales, defense technology transfers,
military training and intelligence cooperation, Singapore has been able
to win a sympathetic hearing at the very heart of Burma's official councils."
Singapore's Stakes
LAST November, Singapore deployed its
diplomatic arsenal to defend Rangoon at the UN. Singaporean UN representatives
made an effort to water down the General Assembly resolution which castigated
the Burmese government for its harsh treatment of pro-democracy activists,
widespread human rights violations, and nullification of free and fair
elections that had voted it out of power. In an "urgent" letter to the
Swedish mission, which was drafting the resolution, Singapore representative
Bilahari Kausikan cited "progress" in Burma and said that "the majority
of your co-sponsors have little or no substantive interests in Myanmar.
...Our position is different. We have concrete and immediate stakes."
Objecting to parts of the resolution and
attempting to soften the language, Singapore's representative circulated
the letter to key members of the UN's Third Committee on Human Rights "The
driving force was definitely business connections," according to Dr. Thaung
Htun, Representative for UN Affairs of Burma's government-in-exile. "Singapore
is defending its investments at the diplomatic level, using its efforts
at the UN level to promote its business interests."
The protection of Singapore's "concrete
and immediate stakes" is essential to the ruling party's success in maintaining
power and the basis of its support for Burma, said Case Western Reserve
University economist Christopher Lingle. "Singapore depends heavily upon
its symbiotic relationship with crony capitalists and upon accommodating
a high enough rate of return to keep the citizenry in line. Therefore its
very survival is tied up with business and government investments." William
Ashton, writing in Jane's Intelligence Review, suggested an additional
incentive for Singapore's alliance with Burma. As Rangoon's major regional
backer and strategic ally, China has provided much of the weaponry, training,
and financial assistance for the junta. China's expanding commercial and
strategic interests in the Asia-Pacific region, coupled with its alliance
with neighboring Burma, is a source of great concern in Singapore. The
desire to keep Burma from becoming Beijing's stalking horse in the region
may provide another motivation for Singapore's wooing of Rangoon.
Turning a Blind Eye
THE Singapore government has consistently
disregarded the gross human rights violations perpetrated by its allies
in Burma. The UN Special Rapporteur, appointed to report to the United
Nations on the situation in Burma, has been barred entry into Burma since
1995. The new US State Department Country report on Burma for 1997 states
that its "longstanding severe repression of human rights continued during
the year. Citizens continued to live subject at any time and without appeal
to the arbitrary and sometimes brutal dictates of the military dictatorship."
Amnesty International reports that there are well over 1,200 political
prisoners languishing in Burmese dungeons where torture is commonplace.
Singapore has issued no urgent letters
about a recent report by Danish Doctors for Human Rights which noted that
"sixty-six percent of [the over 120,000] refugees from Burma now living
in Thailand have been tortured" and subjected to "forced labor, deportation,
pillaging, destruction of villages, and various forms of torture and rape."
The doctors reported that refugees witnessed the junta's military forces
murder members of their families. Singaporean leaders also seem unconcerned
about the fact that the Burmese government shut down almost all of Burma's
colleges and universities following student protests in December of 1996
and imprisoned hundreds of students. At a February ceremony of the Singapore
Association in Myanmar, the Ambassador to Singapore presented a large check
to Gen. Khin Nyunt - who is also Chairman of the government Education Committee
- for the "Myanmar education development fund." While depriving young Burmese
of higher education, the junta's "Secretary 1" Khin Nyunt responded that
"Uplifting the educational standards of our people is one of the social
objectives of our Government." He then went on at length to extol the "firm
foundation of growing economic and trade ties" between Singapore and Burma.
The Burmese government has also kept computers
and communication technology away from students and others in opposition
to the regime. All computers, software, email services and other telecommunication
devices - which hardly anyone can afford anyway - must be licensed, but
licences are almost impossible to obtain. Yet Singapore has made the best
computer technology available to the ruling elite and their business partners.
Singapore Telecom, the largest company in Asia outside of Japan, was the
first to provide Burmese businesses and government offices with the ability
to set up inter-and intra-corporate communications in more than 90 countries.
Complimentary Relations
SINGAPORE's concerns are dramatically
different from those of countries sharing a border with Burma. Thailand
has to deal with the deadly narcotics trade and an overwhelming number
of refugees arriving on a daily basis. Banphot Piamdi, the Thai counter-narcotics
official, believes Thailand made a big mistake when it voted for Burma's
entry into the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (asean), given Burma's
lack of cooperation in fighting drugs. Not surprisingly, the Singapore
government lobbied hard for Burma's 1997 acceptance into the powerful regional
trade alliance.
Ironically, Burma's inclusion in asean
may force member nations, including Singapore, to address the havoc that
their newest ally is imposing on the region - especially since Burma provides
approximately 90 percent of the total production of Southeast Asian opium.
China and India, Burma's other neighbors, now face severe aids epidemics
related to increased heroin use in their bordering provinces. Most of the
heroin exported from Burma to the West passes through China's Yunnan province,
which now has more than half a million addicts. And even Singapore - whose
heroin supply comes mostly from Burma - had a 41 percent rise in HIV cases
in 1997.
As we head into the "Asian century," Singapore
has become Washington's forward partner in the unfolding era of East-West
trade. Ambassador Green called the country "a major entry port and a natural
gateway to Asia for American firms." US companies exported $16 billion
worth of goods to Singapore in 1996 and more than 1,300 US firms now operate
in the country. Singapore's strategic and economic importance to the US
cannot be overstated. The two countries just reached an agreement allowing
the US Navy to use a Singapore base even though the deal violates asean's
1997 nuclear-weapons-free zone agreement.
The US has condemned the Burmese junta's
record of human rights abuses and support for the drug trade, but has turned
a blind eye when it comes to Singapore's dealings with the regime. Although
President Clinton imposed economic sanctions on Burma partly for it's role
in providing pure and cheap heroin to America's youth, he has not commented
on Singapore's willingness to play ball with the world's biggest heroin
traffickers. Ambassador Green told Congress last year that the US "has
an important role in working with the Singapore government to deal with
illegal drug and weapons proliferation issues," but most US officials have
remianed silent about Singapore's investments with Lo Hsing Han and Burma's
narco-dictatorship. It's unlikely Clinton made any mention of this issue
last fall while golfing with Singaporean Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong during
the apec summit in Vancouver.
Unless the financial crisis in Asia limits
profits, Singapore will probably continue to expand its investments in
Burma. "Our two economies are complementary and although we can derive
satisfaction from the progress made, I believe that there still remains
a great potential that is yet to be exploited," said the junta's Gen. Khin
Nyunt last February. Aided by Singapore's support, Burma's thriving heroin
trade has plagued the majority of countries around the globe. While these
countries blithely pour money into drug-connected companies based in Burma
and thereby help them to expand into foreign markets, an abundance of the
world's finest heroin continues to plague their citizens. At the same time,
the line between legitimate and illegitimate investments grows dimmer in
the global economy.
|| home
|| back
||
|